Barack Obama's been making a lot of waves recently with his speech in New Hampshire (and, of course, on Monday Night Football.) The big split among leftist political junkies is whether he's got the necessary substance - whether he would work to lionize the liberal cause, and fight good fights, or whether he would be a politically-expedient triangulator. As a Chicagoan recently entertained by his Bears endorsement, I think it's too early to judge Obama on substance. I mean, for Chrissakes, in terms of Senatorial power, he ranked at 100th since gaining office. You can't even propose legislation of import when you're that far down the totem pole (and, let's not forget, in the minority.) I do like what he has been pushing for - commonsense legislation not designed to pick fights. I don't think it's particularly important for him to be the guy to sponsor, say, anti-torture legislation, either, since I trust his voting record enough to know he'll vote well, and again, other, more experienced Senators (don't dismiss the importance of procedural knowledge in getting things done) will more easily get it through.
I do, however, also think that it's important for him to start taking stands, but he's got some time left before the backlash reaches a level where that's necessary - besides, he doesn't seem like he's running for sure yet. I understand criticism regarding experience and accomplishment, but experience for an executive position simply doesn't come from a legislative one - the vast majority of Congresspersons don't do a whole lot of high-flying foreign diplomacy. (People like Curt Weldon, on the other hand, engaged in foreign diplomacy as if he were so high he was flying. Zing!) Ambition, too, is no sin, and I wish we wouldn't consider it one in and of itself. The real test is whether he wants to bring the nation together to face issues or to bring the nation together to vote him in - and that, I think, is what we some be keeping an eye on once Congress is back in session.
His rhetoric, however, is utterly full of grace, actually making vague ideas look like more than platitudes. Also recall that his only real tangle politically so far was with John McCain - a media darling who he utterly embarrassed. I know I can trust his political instincts, and we all should (unless things fall apart after the honeymoon *finally* ends). We just need to wait and see if his civic instincts can match that level. I hope they will, but it's too early for anybody to say for sure.
UPDATE: Stay classy, CNN!
12.13.2006
12.10.2006
Unmatched arrogance
It's really worth taking a look at this article about reactions to the Baker panel's recommendations.
The sheer petulance on the behalf of leading neoconservatives - those bright lights who led this administration into the single most monumental governmental failure of the past 30 years - is astonishing. That this group would express so much dissatisfaction for being left out of the conversation is no surprise - even in failure, they have remained overwhelmingly confident. However, should it shock anybody else that a commission designed to work against these wrongs would leave out the architects of the catastrophe?
John "Straight Talk" McCain is referenced in the article, disputing the findings of the study for going against his plan - adding more troops to Iraq. However, the numbers required for this plan to work grow more out of hand as time passes by. Though 40,000 more troops may have made a significant difference at the outset of the war, adding such a number now would have nowhere near the same effect. It's political chicanery, but we've found that the only time pie-in-the-sky predictions hurt you is when you actually expect them to happen (see: Iraq.)
In DC, this war will end like Vietnam did. We will leave, trying our best to claim a moral victory from obvious failure. The Right will accuse American citizens - mostly the liberals - of losing the war for us, and lay little to no responsibility at the hands of its architects - those who ginned up the case and had us ready for the Rapture at the hands of a loosely-defined threat. They're going to try and make this into a matter of liberals letting their own wives be raped and murdered - a gaggle of anemic technocrats without the heart to fight for what they love. However, it's not going to happen this time. The end of Vietnam occurred in the face of intense public pressure, and Iraq faces similar resistance as well. Unlike Vietnam, though, opposition to this war has been anything but organized and unified - protests on the level of the 60's have been nowhere in sight, and even the opposition party hasn't fully recanted their support for the idea of the war. This has simply been a matter of the realities on the ground being too much for political gamesmanship to overcome, and continued spin will only serve to highlight that fact.
The sheer petulance on the behalf of leading neoconservatives - those bright lights who led this administration into the single most monumental governmental failure of the past 30 years - is astonishing. That this group would express so much dissatisfaction for being left out of the conversation is no surprise - even in failure, they have remained overwhelmingly confident. However, should it shock anybody else that a commission designed to work against these wrongs would leave out the architects of the catastrophe?
John "Straight Talk" McCain is referenced in the article, disputing the findings of the study for going against his plan - adding more troops to Iraq. However, the numbers required for this plan to work grow more out of hand as time passes by. Though 40,000 more troops may have made a significant difference at the outset of the war, adding such a number now would have nowhere near the same effect. It's political chicanery, but we've found that the only time pie-in-the-sky predictions hurt you is when you actually expect them to happen (see: Iraq.)
In DC, this war will end like Vietnam did. We will leave, trying our best to claim a moral victory from obvious failure. The Right will accuse American citizens - mostly the liberals - of losing the war for us, and lay little to no responsibility at the hands of its architects - those who ginned up the case and had us ready for the Rapture at the hands of a loosely-defined threat. They're going to try and make this into a matter of liberals letting their own wives be raped and murdered - a gaggle of anemic technocrats without the heart to fight for what they love. However, it's not going to happen this time. The end of Vietnam occurred in the face of intense public pressure, and Iraq faces similar resistance as well. Unlike Vietnam, though, opposition to this war has been anything but organized and unified - protests on the level of the 60's have been nowhere in sight, and even the opposition party hasn't fully recanted their support for the idea of the war. This has simply been a matter of the realities on the ground being too much for political gamesmanship to overcome, and continued spin will only serve to highlight that fact.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)