Barack Obama's been making a lot of waves recently with his speech in New Hampshire (and, of course, on Monday Night Football.) The big split among leftist political junkies is whether he's got the necessary substance - whether he would work to lionize the liberal cause, and fight good fights, or whether he would be a politically-expedient triangulator. As a Chicagoan recently entertained by his Bears endorsement, I think it's too early to judge Obama on substance. I mean, for Chrissakes, in terms of Senatorial power, he ranked at 100th since gaining office. You can't even propose legislation of import when you're that far down the totem pole (and, let's not forget, in the minority.) I do like what he has been pushing for - commonsense legislation not designed to pick fights. I don't think it's particularly important for him to be the guy to sponsor, say, anti-torture legislation, either, since I trust his voting record enough to know he'll vote well, and again, other, more experienced Senators (don't dismiss the importance of procedural knowledge in getting things done) will more easily get it through.
I do, however, also think that it's important for him to start taking stands, but he's got some time left before the backlash reaches a level where that's necessary - besides, he doesn't seem like he's running for sure yet. I understand criticism regarding experience and accomplishment, but experience for an executive position simply doesn't come from a legislative one - the vast majority of Congresspersons don't do a whole lot of high-flying foreign diplomacy. (People like Curt Weldon, on the other hand, engaged in foreign diplomacy as if he were so high he was flying. Zing!) Ambition, too, is no sin, and I wish we wouldn't consider it one in and of itself. The real test is whether he wants to bring the nation together to face issues or to bring the nation together to vote him in - and that, I think, is what we some be keeping an eye on once Congress is back in session.
His rhetoric, however, is utterly full of grace, actually making vague ideas look like more than platitudes. Also recall that his only real tangle politically so far was with John McCain - a media darling who he utterly embarrassed. I know I can trust his political instincts, and we all should (unless things fall apart after the honeymoon *finally* ends). We just need to wait and see if his civic instincts can match that level. I hope they will, but it's too early for anybody to say for sure.
UPDATE: Stay classy, CNN!
12.13.2006
12.10.2006
Unmatched arrogance
It's really worth taking a look at this article about reactions to the Baker panel's recommendations.
The sheer petulance on the behalf of leading neoconservatives - those bright lights who led this administration into the single most monumental governmental failure of the past 30 years - is astonishing. That this group would express so much dissatisfaction for being left out of the conversation is no surprise - even in failure, they have remained overwhelmingly confident. However, should it shock anybody else that a commission designed to work against these wrongs would leave out the architects of the catastrophe?
John "Straight Talk" McCain is referenced in the article, disputing the findings of the study for going against his plan - adding more troops to Iraq. However, the numbers required for this plan to work grow more out of hand as time passes by. Though 40,000 more troops may have made a significant difference at the outset of the war, adding such a number now would have nowhere near the same effect. It's political chicanery, but we've found that the only time pie-in-the-sky predictions hurt you is when you actually expect them to happen (see: Iraq.)
In DC, this war will end like Vietnam did. We will leave, trying our best to claim a moral victory from obvious failure. The Right will accuse American citizens - mostly the liberals - of losing the war for us, and lay little to no responsibility at the hands of its architects - those who ginned up the case and had us ready for the Rapture at the hands of a loosely-defined threat. They're going to try and make this into a matter of liberals letting their own wives be raped and murdered - a gaggle of anemic technocrats without the heart to fight for what they love. However, it's not going to happen this time. The end of Vietnam occurred in the face of intense public pressure, and Iraq faces similar resistance as well. Unlike Vietnam, though, opposition to this war has been anything but organized and unified - protests on the level of the 60's have been nowhere in sight, and even the opposition party hasn't fully recanted their support for the idea of the war. This has simply been a matter of the realities on the ground being too much for political gamesmanship to overcome, and continued spin will only serve to highlight that fact.
The sheer petulance on the behalf of leading neoconservatives - those bright lights who led this administration into the single most monumental governmental failure of the past 30 years - is astonishing. That this group would express so much dissatisfaction for being left out of the conversation is no surprise - even in failure, they have remained overwhelmingly confident. However, should it shock anybody else that a commission designed to work against these wrongs would leave out the architects of the catastrophe?
John "Straight Talk" McCain is referenced in the article, disputing the findings of the study for going against his plan - adding more troops to Iraq. However, the numbers required for this plan to work grow more out of hand as time passes by. Though 40,000 more troops may have made a significant difference at the outset of the war, adding such a number now would have nowhere near the same effect. It's political chicanery, but we've found that the only time pie-in-the-sky predictions hurt you is when you actually expect them to happen (see: Iraq.)
In DC, this war will end like Vietnam did. We will leave, trying our best to claim a moral victory from obvious failure. The Right will accuse American citizens - mostly the liberals - of losing the war for us, and lay little to no responsibility at the hands of its architects - those who ginned up the case and had us ready for the Rapture at the hands of a loosely-defined threat. They're going to try and make this into a matter of liberals letting their own wives be raped and murdered - a gaggle of anemic technocrats without the heart to fight for what they love. However, it's not going to happen this time. The end of Vietnam occurred in the face of intense public pressure, and Iraq faces similar resistance as well. Unlike Vietnam, though, opposition to this war has been anything but organized and unified - protests on the level of the 60's have been nowhere in sight, and even the opposition party hasn't fully recanted their support for the idea of the war. This has simply been a matter of the realities on the ground being too much for political gamesmanship to overcome, and continued spin will only serve to highlight that fact.
11.29.2006
McCain: Boogeyman
I can't help but note that our friends at Urbanagora have been pretty John McCain-focused as of late. And I can't blame them. After all, his only flaw is a preternatural tendency to change what he says based on his audience for political points. And when has being politically inconsistent ever hurt anybody?
11.28.2006
Lemonade
So, back from tour, took a break.
Countdown with Keith Olbermann tonight featured Paul Mooney pretty much taking the opportunity to say something brilliant about the N word. Chances are, you're familiar with Paul Mooney from Chappelle's Show, or his work with Richard Pryor, or from Saturday Night Live's olden days. In any case, if you're familiar with his work at all, you know he drops N-bombs left and right in his comedy. At the same time, he's known Michael Richards for 20 years, and believes Richards to be contrite in his apology. In light of the horror of the clip, Mooney has sworn off using the N-word in his routines. In short, he doesn't want to normalize it any further. The interview with Olbermann is noteworthy, and Olbermann asks an interesting question about other racially-inflected comedians, such as Margaret Cho, Carlos Mencia, and Sacha Baron Cohen. You can find a link to the video at the above link.
Countdown with Keith Olbermann tonight featured Paul Mooney pretty much taking the opportunity to say something brilliant about the N word. Chances are, you're familiar with Paul Mooney from Chappelle's Show, or his work with Richard Pryor, or from Saturday Night Live's olden days. In any case, if you're familiar with his work at all, you know he drops N-bombs left and right in his comedy. At the same time, he's known Michael Richards for 20 years, and believes Richards to be contrite in his apology. In light of the horror of the clip, Mooney has sworn off using the N-word in his routines. In short, he doesn't want to normalize it any further. The interview with Olbermann is noteworthy, and Olbermann asks an interesting question about other racially-inflected comedians, such as Margaret Cho, Carlos Mencia, and Sacha Baron Cohen. You can find a link to the video at the above link.
11.08.2006
Election Postmortem
Call it a mandate! Do it!
We shouldn't even have been able to win the Senate in this geographically-unfriendly year. There's no reason we should have been competitive in Tennessee, or Montana, or Virginia, or Arizona. It looks like, nationwide, people had had enough of Republican governance.
Also, we won a larger margin in the House than I had expected. Hooray!
We shouldn't even have been able to win the Senate in this geographically-unfriendly year. There's no reason we should have been competitive in Tennessee, or Montana, or Virginia, or Arizona. It looks like, nationwide, people had had enough of Republican governance.
Also, we won a larger margin in the House than I had expected. Hooray!
11.02.2006
Hey, Listen
Look, I just waded into the war between Left and Lefter , and it's just a shame. I had planned to do a couple significant posts on my feelings about those two parties, but to hell with it, I'm going to simply say this.
If you're a Democrat, and you equate the Greens with Republicans, that's a shitty thing to do.
If you're a Green, and you equate the Democrats with Republicans, that's a shitty thing to do.
In response to Jack McMillin's column: Yes, there are shameful situations of a Green receiving too much support from Republicans - most recently Carl Romanelli's attempt Senate run in Pennsylvania - a race where 99% of the declared contributions came from conservative voters and activists. However, the party as a whole is a group of people dedicated to their principles - working to affect progressive change - and you gotta respect that.
In response to Lally Gartel's column: Yes, there are shameful situations of a Democrat providing too much support from Republicans - most recently Joe Lieberman's Senate run to the right - a race where the national GOP hasn't even endorsed the Republican candidate. However, the party as a whole is a group of people dedicated to their principles - working to affect progressive change - and you gotta respect that.
Bottomline: we ought not take our time fighting these fights when the Republican party is spitting in our drinks.
Signed,
a publically-funded-elections-endorsing happy Democrat
PS. I'm going on tour tomorrow. I probably won't see any comments for a while (but then again, I haven't seen any comments for a while.) See you all after the election when hopefully we're headed in the right direction again.
If you're a Democrat, and you equate the Greens with Republicans, that's a shitty thing to do.
If you're a Green, and you equate the Democrats with Republicans, that's a shitty thing to do.
In response to Jack McMillin's column: Yes, there are shameful situations of a Green receiving too much support from Republicans - most recently Carl Romanelli's attempt Senate run in Pennsylvania - a race where 99% of the declared contributions came from conservative voters and activists. However, the party as a whole is a group of people dedicated to their principles - working to affect progressive change - and you gotta respect that.
In response to Lally Gartel's column: Yes, there are shameful situations of a Democrat providing too much support from Republicans - most recently Joe Lieberman's Senate run to the right - a race where the national GOP hasn't even endorsed the Republican candidate. However, the party as a whole is a group of people dedicated to their principles - working to affect progressive change - and you gotta respect that.
Bottomline: we ought not take our time fighting these fights when the Republican party is spitting in our drinks.
Signed,
a publically-funded-elections-endorsing happy Democrat
PS. I'm going on tour tomorrow. I probably won't see any comments for a while (but then again, I haven't seen any comments for a while.) See you all after the election when hopefully we're headed in the right direction again.
10.31.2006
Voting
So I voted absentee today (on the 7th, I will be in NYC) - who for, you ask?
Gov: Rich Whitney
I'm not a Rod Blagojevich fan. I outright fear the notion of a Governor Topinka - or rather, I would, if she were capable of polling within 6 points of Blagojevich. You may note that most polls total up to just under 80 percent - I hear choruses of "they could break against the incumbent!" - but unpresented in these figures is the impressive performance of Rich Whitney, who will probably break 10 percent on protest votes alone. Protest is a good reason for conservatives to vote his way - or did you think it was the universal healthcare/renewable energy policy cocktail? - but for progressives, he's a very good candidate.
House Rep: David Gill
I will say this for Tim Johnson - he's less offensive than most Republican House members. But "relatively inoffensive" is no substitute for what David Gill offers. He also runs a much classier, more polite campaign than most politicians - which is probably why this race wasn't on any list of competitive races to watch.
State Sen: Mike Frerichs
Take a look at their two websites. See the two news feeds? The Frerichs page contains a list of press releases Frerichs has made - not a single mention of his opponent. The Myers page includes a news page with items including titles such as (mendacity alert!) "TRUTH ALERT!: Frerichs uses Chicago money to bash Senator Judy Myers". This is a what contrast looks like. On top of that, the posts on The Official Judy Myers Fanblog routinely decry the negativity in the Frerichs campaign. This is slime I can't abide, and because of it, I don't even get the opportunity to say I'm voting Frerichs on the issues.
And as an aside to Joe Parnarauskis - please don't run for state office on a federal issue. I know, I know, that's a fuzzy line sometimes. Usage of the military, though? Illinois' 52nd doesn't get to say much about that.
State House: Tom Abram
I've got nothing against Naomi Jakobsson. I actually like the job she's done, and I also like the sour grapes on the J-My Fanblog. However, the fact remains that she could be doing a lot more in providing the U of I with much-need largesse. I have to say I'm not voting against her so much as I am voting for Tom Abram, Green Party candidate.
Full disclosure: I know Tom Abram, and in fact a fair number of the Greens on campus. They're intelligent, organized and stand a good chance of making the Green Party a permanent fixture in this area. The selection of Abram as their candidate, too, was truly putting their best foot forward. Abram's platform contains plenty of things I'm extremely happy to see, especially a page on electoral reform - an absolute necessity in Illinois, arguably one of the hardest states to vote and run for office in.
Nothing against candidates Jakobsson and Rex "Max Power" Bradfield. In the future, however, Jakobsson really should look into making webpages for her candidacy.
------------(I sure did forget how to make a divider line in HTML)-------------------
On other races, I mostly voted Democratic, but in any case don't feel strongly enough about it to be posting my decisions.
In other news, check out this delightful policy work. This shit has got to be frustrating to:
-Liberals/progressives, in that same "are you kidding me?!" way we've gotten so used to
-Small government conservatives, for adding to the list of obscenely useless things the government spends your money on
-Religious conservatives, for defusing the argument for Intelligent Design
Gov: Rich Whitney
I'm not a Rod Blagojevich fan. I outright fear the notion of a Governor Topinka - or rather, I would, if she were capable of polling within 6 points of Blagojevich. You may note that most polls total up to just under 80 percent - I hear choruses of "they could break against the incumbent!" - but unpresented in these figures is the impressive performance of Rich Whitney, who will probably break 10 percent on protest votes alone. Protest is a good reason for conservatives to vote his way - or did you think it was the universal healthcare/renewable energy policy cocktail? - but for progressives, he's a very good candidate.
House Rep: David Gill
I will say this for Tim Johnson - he's less offensive than most Republican House members. But "relatively inoffensive" is no substitute for what David Gill offers. He also runs a much classier, more polite campaign than most politicians - which is probably why this race wasn't on any list of competitive races to watch.
State Sen: Mike Frerichs
Take a look at their two websites. See the two news feeds? The Frerichs page contains a list of press releases Frerichs has made - not a single mention of his opponent. The Myers page includes a news page with items including titles such as (mendacity alert!) "TRUTH ALERT!: Frerichs uses Chicago money to bash Senator Judy Myers". This is a what contrast looks like. On top of that, the posts on The Official Judy Myers Fanblog routinely decry the negativity in the Frerichs campaign. This is slime I can't abide, and because of it, I don't even get the opportunity to say I'm voting Frerichs on the issues.
And as an aside to Joe Parnarauskis - please don't run for state office on a federal issue. I know, I know, that's a fuzzy line sometimes. Usage of the military, though? Illinois' 52nd doesn't get to say much about that.
State House: Tom Abram
I've got nothing against Naomi Jakobsson. I actually like the job she's done, and I also like the sour grapes on the J-My Fanblog. However, the fact remains that she could be doing a lot more in providing the U of I with much-need largesse. I have to say I'm not voting against her so much as I am voting for Tom Abram, Green Party candidate.
Full disclosure: I know Tom Abram, and in fact a fair number of the Greens on campus. They're intelligent, organized and stand a good chance of making the Green Party a permanent fixture in this area. The selection of Abram as their candidate, too, was truly putting their best foot forward. Abram's platform contains plenty of things I'm extremely happy to see, especially a page on electoral reform - an absolute necessity in Illinois, arguably one of the hardest states to vote and run for office in.
Nothing against candidates Jakobsson and Rex "Max Power" Bradfield. In the future, however, Jakobsson really should look into making webpages for her candidacy.
------------(I sure did forget how to make a divider line in HTML)-------------------
On other races, I mostly voted Democratic, but in any case don't feel strongly enough about it to be posting my decisions.
In other news, check out this delightful policy work. This shit has got to be frustrating to:
-Liberals/progressives, in that same "are you kidding me?!" way we've gotten so used to
-Small government conservatives, for adding to the list of obscenely useless things the government spends your money on
-Religious conservatives, for defusing the argument for Intelligent Design
10.27.2006
Turkish Revisions
So, you may have heard about this story - apparently, a publisher in Turkey has been printing new versions of classic novels with Islam interjected.
Although at first the notion of Tom Sawyer leading Islamic prayer is a shock, I'm not sure there's as much to it as the comments at Free Republicans suggest. The Sun article is little more than a collection of random lines throughout the books, removed from context. It is worth noting that these lines taken from the books don't appear to have much to do with the plots to the novels whatsoever. At that, most of these appear to have been related to Christianity originally (I do believe Christianity proper made a number of appearances in a few of those novels.)
Based on the most damning evidence of Creeping Islamocommunazi Threat presented by the NY Sun, this appears to be more a matter of localization (i.e. changing certain passages to be better understood by foreign audiences) than anything else. It's been a long time since I've read it, but I do recall swear words and (antiquated) slang in Tom Sawyer, as well. I'm not entirely sure why slurs against the president and prime minister were included, unless they were also clumsy attempts at localization.
I'd like to note, however, that these are my opinions about this with regard to the NY Sun article only, and should more significant changes appear in these novels, I'll be decrying them along with those to my left and right - I'm no fan of literary sacrilege.
Although at first the notion of Tom Sawyer leading Islamic prayer is a shock, I'm not sure there's as much to it as the comments at Free Republicans suggest. The Sun article is little more than a collection of random lines throughout the books, removed from context. It is worth noting that these lines taken from the books don't appear to have much to do with the plots to the novels whatsoever. At that, most of these appear to have been related to Christianity originally (I do believe Christianity proper made a number of appearances in a few of those novels.)
Based on the most damning evidence of Creeping Islamocommunazi Threat presented by the NY Sun, this appears to be more a matter of localization (i.e. changing certain passages to be better understood by foreign audiences) than anything else. It's been a long time since I've read it, but I do recall swear words and (antiquated) slang in Tom Sawyer, as well. I'm not entirely sure why slurs against the president and prime minister were included, unless they were also clumsy attempts at localization.
I'd like to note, however, that these are my opinions about this with regard to the NY Sun article only, and should more significant changes appear in these novels, I'll be decrying them along with those to my left and right - I'm no fan of literary sacrilege.
10.24.2006
10.23.2006
Supply-Side Economics
The assumption by - oh, about half of the polity over the past couple years has been that the Bush tax cuts pay for themselves in increased revenue. This is based on the assumption that the United States has been living on the right side of the Laffer curve after the Presidency of that dastardly Clinton.
Unfortunately, the most optimistic accounts of these tax cuts' effects have them only adding revenue totalling a fraction of the revenue lost to cuts. The Street Light has more on this.
Unfortunately, the most optimistic accounts of these tax cuts' effects have them only adding revenue totalling a fraction of the revenue lost to cuts. The Street Light has more on this.
10.20.2006
Malignant Comedy
Hey, I return. Sorry, I was busy hanging out with Harvey Danger.
Here's an editorial Jess and I worked on today. With luck, it may appear in the DI... or not, whatever:
The infamous “Tacos and Tequila” party has ignited a great deal of discussion about racial stereotyping on our campus. The party was reprehensible, but symptomatic of a larger problem – the embrace of stereotyping as a response to political correctness (the new Red Menace.) Just a few weeks after this party, comedian Carlos Mencia will visit the U of I Assembly Hall as part of his Punisher tour. By looking at the style and popularity of Mencia, it is not hard to see how college students could possibly think that wearing wife beaters and stuffing one’s shirt to appear pregnant at a Hispanic themed party could be acceptable.
The issue with Carlos Mencia’s comedic stylings is inflamed by his own protestations on the matter. Although his standard defense of his work runs along the lines of “it’s only comedy”, this proclamation, often delivered within one of his standup routines, acknowledges a truth that strengthens the appeal of Richard Pryor, Jeff Foxworthy, and yes, Dave Chappelle – it’s not just comedy, it’s commentary. Mencia’s strident tone and oh-no-he-didn’t “courageousness” serve to portray him as a truthteller – a court jester who says what others are forbidden to say – but it’s a poor fit. His routine – dependent on racial, religious, and sexual divisions for success – is no revelation of outlawed truths, but rather a lazy recitation of stereotypes we’ve all heard before.
The Chappelle comparisons, trumpeted by critics and fans alike, illustrate how far apart the two are. Dave Chappelle, vanished star of his own sketch comedy show, built his career on the absurdity of society’s ethnic divisions. Even sketches he found too controversial (most notably the “race pixie” sketch, in which people of different ethnicities are tormented by the pressure to conform to stereotypes via miniature minstrels and the like) showed human beings at the other end of the joke. Chappelle’s Show was a rare achievement in the way it opened up racial dialogue. Sadly, Chappelle left his show out of concern that his audience might misread the message as an acceptance of stereotyping. This concern was apparently well-founded, as evidenced by Mencia’s popularity and the Tacos and Tequila debacle.
Carlos Mencia makes a point of telling us that as a comedian, he’s only telling jokes. However, comedy is not a benign force, and as a leading comedian, his divisive brand of humor influences acceptable discourse in society at large. It’s unfortunate that he received his platform as a result of the work of Dave Chappelle, a comedian who opened up a critical dialogue on race in a way that only comedy could. Mencia’s work, however, demolishes the progress made by Chappelle’s Show – a sad case of one step forward, two steps back.
Here's an editorial Jess and I worked on today. With luck, it may appear in the DI... or not, whatever:
The infamous “Tacos and Tequila” party has ignited a great deal of discussion about racial stereotyping on our campus. The party was reprehensible, but symptomatic of a larger problem – the embrace of stereotyping as a response to political correctness (the new Red Menace.) Just a few weeks after this party, comedian Carlos Mencia will visit the U of I Assembly Hall as part of his Punisher tour. By looking at the style and popularity of Mencia, it is not hard to see how college students could possibly think that wearing wife beaters and stuffing one’s shirt to appear pregnant at a Hispanic themed party could be acceptable.
The issue with Carlos Mencia’s comedic stylings is inflamed by his own protestations on the matter. Although his standard defense of his work runs along the lines of “it’s only comedy”, this proclamation, often delivered within one of his standup routines, acknowledges a truth that strengthens the appeal of Richard Pryor, Jeff Foxworthy, and yes, Dave Chappelle – it’s not just comedy, it’s commentary. Mencia’s strident tone and oh-no-he-didn’t “courageousness” serve to portray him as a truthteller – a court jester who says what others are forbidden to say – but it’s a poor fit. His routine – dependent on racial, religious, and sexual divisions for success – is no revelation of outlawed truths, but rather a lazy recitation of stereotypes we’ve all heard before.
The Chappelle comparisons, trumpeted by critics and fans alike, illustrate how far apart the two are. Dave Chappelle, vanished star of his own sketch comedy show, built his career on the absurdity of society’s ethnic divisions. Even sketches he found too controversial (most notably the “race pixie” sketch, in which people of different ethnicities are tormented by the pressure to conform to stereotypes via miniature minstrels and the like) showed human beings at the other end of the joke. Chappelle’s Show was a rare achievement in the way it opened up racial dialogue. Sadly, Chappelle left his show out of concern that his audience might misread the message as an acceptance of stereotyping. This concern was apparently well-founded, as evidenced by Mencia’s popularity and the Tacos and Tequila debacle.
Carlos Mencia makes a point of telling us that as a comedian, he’s only telling jokes. However, comedy is not a benign force, and as a leading comedian, his divisive brand of humor influences acceptable discourse in society at large. It’s unfortunate that he received his platform as a result of the work of Dave Chappelle, a comedian who opened up a critical dialogue on race in a way that only comedy could. Mencia’s work, however, demolishes the progress made by Chappelle’s Show – a sad case of one step forward, two steps back.
10.04.2006
GOP: Trying to derail the Foley train
Alright, so they tried to pin the blame for the Foley cover-up on Democrats, where the vast majority of evidence says they were themselves responsible. Now that Democrats are off the table as a target, they've got a new idea: It was the GAAAAAYS!!!
Well, that'll bring the family values crowd back to the polls, if nothing else. For shame.
To clarify here, this is something that hasn't arisen yet. But Josh Marshall isn't often wrong about these things - when he picks a topic, he follows it doggedly and is regularly the first one to break news. Witness his work with Abramoff, Social Security, and Jeff Gannon.
Update: Hannity: Aravosis to blame.
Well, that'll bring the family values crowd back to the polls, if nothing else. For shame.
To clarify here, this is something that hasn't arisen yet. But Josh Marshall isn't often wrong about these things - when he picks a topic, he follows it doggedly and is regularly the first one to break news. Witness his work with Abramoff, Social Security, and Jeff Gannon.
Update: Hannity: Aravosis to blame.
9.30.2006
20 Reasons Republicans Are In Trouble
Long post today...
20. The REAL pressing issues... gays and flag burning
Sure, they're good for the base, but nowadays, the rest of the country (rightly) see them as what they are... red meat, pure and simple. And given the rest of this list, it is not the right time to be doing this.
19. Alito and Roberts
They made it onto the court just fine, but their rightward shift is something that we're going to have to live with for a while - in 10 years, I think they'll be the big signifier of Bush Conservatism.
18. Underfunding No Child Left Behind
People are split on whether this plan is any good at all (and put me down for against teaching to tests), but we're united in that it hasn't seen the funding it needs.
17. Stem cell stonewalling
Remember when Ronald Reagan died? And Nancy went to Congress to beg them to reconsider stem cell research, to find cures for diseases such as Alzheimers? A hypothetical: You're caught in a fire in a hospital. You have the option of saving two crying babies or thirty blastocysts. What would you select? Most Republicans in Congress go blastocyst.
16. Social Security privatization
The privatization of Social Security removes its use as a security net for those who fall on hard times (i.e. due to the death of a spouse.) Remember that the President selected it as his top domestic priority upon winning re-election, and that it'll be high on the list of priorities again next year.
15. Medicare Part D
Confusing seniors, costing the US Government $900 billion dollars, and not even succeeding in its goal of keeping prescription drugs cheap - this is one ugly piece of legislation.
14. Stagnating real wage growth
Rather than post about this now, I expect somebody will dispute this one, and I can bring the data then.
13. An incredible national deficit
Nobody, on the other hand, is capable of disputing this one. The Ted Stevens Bridge to Nowhere? The aforementioned Medicare Part D? The litany of evidence indicating price gouging by companies working reconstruction efforts in Iraq? President Bush never vetoing a spending bill? This was once the party of fiscal responsibility, but no longer.
12. Harriet Miers and Michael Brown
These two are the clearest and best known examples of pure-and-simple nepotism by the Bush Administration. Congress doesn't hold responsibility for Harriet Miers, but they certainly haven't learned a lesson from this - they haven't done a thing to look at the similar cronyism at work in the reconstruction of Iraq.
11. George "Macaca" Allen
Former 2008 favorite has found himself struggling for electoral survival for a litany of problems. He started off by throwing out an arcane ethnic slur at a campaign fundraiser. Then, he spent about a month test-driving explanations for what he said. Then, he decided to respond by weakly claiming his opponent was sexist. Then, evidence of much worse racism in his past arose. Then, he apologized about defending the confederate flag to reconcile. Then, his friends in the Sons of Confederate Veterans said "we supported him in the past, but no more."
This is the destruction of the most venerated of all Republican wedge issues - the Southern Strategy. Success in national elections has in the past been aided by speaking to everyone and winking to a group of voters you're not allowed to talk to. By angering those voters, Allen is going to see his trouble mount in the coming weeks.
I gotta run now, but I'll be back with part 2. For the curious, my top ten are:
10. Mark Foley (a possible total bombshell, though a new revelation - we need to see)
9. Terri Schiavo (remember when this was the best example of this administration's intrusiveness? Those were the days.)
8. Jack Abramoff (The Scandal Which Will Not End)
7. Innocent people at Guantanamo Bay (Detained without rights, not charged with a crime)
6. Illegal Wiretapping (Today, We Are All Paranoid)
5. Abu Ghraib (How we lost the moral high ground)
4. Osama bin-Hidin (For every time they've flogged 9/11, it's more apparent they haven't gotten justice for it.)
3. Ending the right to habeas corpus (No longer one of the certain inalienable rights.)
2. Iraq war (Are we safer?)
1. Hurricane Katrina response (We are not.)
20. The REAL pressing issues... gays and flag burning
Sure, they're good for the base, but nowadays, the rest of the country (rightly) see them as what they are... red meat, pure and simple. And given the rest of this list, it is not the right time to be doing this.
19. Alito and Roberts
They made it onto the court just fine, but their rightward shift is something that we're going to have to live with for a while - in 10 years, I think they'll be the big signifier of Bush Conservatism.
18. Underfunding No Child Left Behind
People are split on whether this plan is any good at all (and put me down for against teaching to tests), but we're united in that it hasn't seen the funding it needs.
17. Stem cell stonewalling
Remember when Ronald Reagan died? And Nancy went to Congress to beg them to reconsider stem cell research, to find cures for diseases such as Alzheimers? A hypothetical: You're caught in a fire in a hospital. You have the option of saving two crying babies or thirty blastocysts. What would you select? Most Republicans in Congress go blastocyst.
16. Social Security privatization
The privatization of Social Security removes its use as a security net for those who fall on hard times (i.e. due to the death of a spouse.) Remember that the President selected it as his top domestic priority upon winning re-election, and that it'll be high on the list of priorities again next year.
15. Medicare Part D
Confusing seniors, costing the US Government $900 billion dollars, and not even succeeding in its goal of keeping prescription drugs cheap - this is one ugly piece of legislation.
14. Stagnating real wage growth
Rather than post about this now, I expect somebody will dispute this one, and I can bring the data then.
13. An incredible national deficit
Nobody, on the other hand, is capable of disputing this one. The Ted Stevens Bridge to Nowhere? The aforementioned Medicare Part D? The litany of evidence indicating price gouging by companies working reconstruction efforts in Iraq? President Bush never vetoing a spending bill? This was once the party of fiscal responsibility, but no longer.
12. Harriet Miers and Michael Brown
These two are the clearest and best known examples of pure-and-simple nepotism by the Bush Administration. Congress doesn't hold responsibility for Harriet Miers, but they certainly haven't learned a lesson from this - they haven't done a thing to look at the similar cronyism at work in the reconstruction of Iraq.
11. George "Macaca" Allen
Former 2008 favorite has found himself struggling for electoral survival for a litany of problems. He started off by throwing out an arcane ethnic slur at a campaign fundraiser. Then, he spent about a month test-driving explanations for what he said. Then, he decided to respond by weakly claiming his opponent was sexist. Then, evidence of much worse racism in his past arose. Then, he apologized about defending the confederate flag to reconcile. Then, his friends in the Sons of Confederate Veterans said "we supported him in the past, but no more."
This is the destruction of the most venerated of all Republican wedge issues - the Southern Strategy. Success in national elections has in the past been aided by speaking to everyone and winking to a group of voters you're not allowed to talk to. By angering those voters, Allen is going to see his trouble mount in the coming weeks.
I gotta run now, but I'll be back with part 2. For the curious, my top ten are:
10. Mark Foley (a possible total bombshell, though a new revelation - we need to see)
9. Terri Schiavo (remember when this was the best example of this administration's intrusiveness? Those were the days.)
8. Jack Abramoff (The Scandal Which Will Not End)
7. Innocent people at Guantanamo Bay (Detained without rights, not charged with a crime)
6. Illegal Wiretapping (Today, We Are All Paranoid)
5. Abu Ghraib (How we lost the moral high ground)
4. Osama bin-Hidin (For every time they've flogged 9/11, it's more apparent they haven't gotten justice for it.)
3. Ending the right to habeas corpus (No longer one of the certain inalienable rights.)
2. Iraq war (Are we safer?)
1. Hurricane Katrina response (We are not.)
9.29.2006
George Washington
In the spirit of honoring some of history's most significant figures, I would like to share with you this delightful short film about our first President.
He'll save children, but not the British Children.
He'll save children, but not the British Children.
9.26.2006
Oh, Kinky, Why?
I feel intense regret that I ever supported Kinky Friedman's bid for governor. The guy started off being a straight-talking dude with the rare ability to self-deprecate - but then the trigger law for abortion, guardsmen on the Mexican border, and this sub-Macaca shit? Disillusionment with a candidate is a sad thing.
9.24.2006
Wal-Mart: Free Market?
This is a post in respsonse to Billy's defense of Wal-Mart - a topic near and dear to my heart. As per usual, I disagree with him, and here's why: I feel his comments miss the real danger Wal-Mart poses to the American economy - not singularly a problem of wages, but rather that their massive influence allows them to set the tone for the future of our service and manufacturing sectors.
Kevin Drum, writer at the Washington Monthly, has stated that three things keep Wal-Mart's prices so low (and thus, make Wal-Mart successful):
Now, we can all get on board with #1 - productivity is pretty much always a good thing. #3, as you'd imagine, is a real sticking point for many liberals, this one included. I understand some may have a general dislike for unions, but the extent to which Wal-Mart acts to prevent any organized push for higher pay or benefits is ridiculous - the turnover at some of their stores is absurd. #2, though, is what I think is the biggest problem with Wal-Mart, and I would imagine "free-market" conservatives would agree.
Wal-Mart, as it is now, acts as a monopsony - a retailer who actually controls the price at which it purchases from its suppliers. As Ezra notes in the above link, "[t]hey've forced Coke to change their secret recipe, Kraft to lay off thousands of employees, and Vlasic to declare bankruptcy." This is in itself a powerfully deleterious effect independent of wages, and not the only examples of it - since starting to sell their Signature brand at Wal-Mart, Levi's has since closed the last of their U.S. factories. These things, of course, are bad for the companies involved. If you wanted, you could argue that the lost jobs and ruined companies are a small price to pay for more effective consumer prices. However, the street goes both ways. Recently, Wal-Mart has forced major movie studios not to give a better deal to Apple for digital sales than Wal-Mart gets for physical copies. Now, knowing the paltry cost of creating a digital copy compared to an actual DVD, if we're talking efficiency, this is the height of lunacy. However, the studios have no alternative but to comply - Wal-Mart, after all, is responsible for 1/3 of all DVD sales in the US.
The amount of influence Wal-Mart has over so many sectors of the economy is incredible - and though this influence does have positive effects, such as increasing productivity and efficiency among some of its suppliers, its incredible power has also broken several companies, driving them to bankruptcy and outsourcing. At the same time, I can't rightly concede that Wal-Mart has the best business model of all: when comparing their wholesale division, Sam's Club, with union-friendly competitor Costco, the result is surprising - with 212 fewer stores than Sam's Club, they've had sales of $14 billion dollars more, and made a profit of over $1 billion in the past year. With figures like that, can we trust that Wal-Mart is the best of all possible worlds for consumers, companies, and employees? And worse yet, isn't Wal-Mart's singular control over so many industries a perversion of what the free market was made to do?
Kevin Drum, writer at the Washington Monthly, has stated that three things keep Wal-Mart's prices so low (and thus, make Wal-Mart successful):
1.A spectacularly efficient supply chain and logistics system that's the envy of the industry.
2.A willingness - in fact, an almost palpable enthusiasm - for using their enormous size to beat the lowest possible prices out of their suppliers.
3.A scorched-earth campaign to prevent unions from organizing at Wal-Mart sites, thus keeping wages and benefits as low as possible.
Now, we can all get on board with #1 - productivity is pretty much always a good thing. #3, as you'd imagine, is a real sticking point for many liberals, this one included. I understand some may have a general dislike for unions, but the extent to which Wal-Mart acts to prevent any organized push for higher pay or benefits is ridiculous - the turnover at some of their stores is absurd. #2, though, is what I think is the biggest problem with Wal-Mart, and I would imagine "free-market" conservatives would agree.
Wal-Mart, as it is now, acts as a monopsony - a retailer who actually controls the price at which it purchases from its suppliers. As Ezra notes in the above link, "[t]hey've forced Coke to change their secret recipe, Kraft to lay off thousands of employees, and Vlasic to declare bankruptcy." This is in itself a powerfully deleterious effect independent of wages, and not the only examples of it - since starting to sell their Signature brand at Wal-Mart, Levi's has since closed the last of their U.S. factories. These things, of course, are bad for the companies involved. If you wanted, you could argue that the lost jobs and ruined companies are a small price to pay for more effective consumer prices. However, the street goes both ways. Recently, Wal-Mart has forced major movie studios not to give a better deal to Apple for digital sales than Wal-Mart gets for physical copies. Now, knowing the paltry cost of creating a digital copy compared to an actual DVD, if we're talking efficiency, this is the height of lunacy. However, the studios have no alternative but to comply - Wal-Mart, after all, is responsible for 1/3 of all DVD sales in the US.
The amount of influence Wal-Mart has over so many sectors of the economy is incredible - and though this influence does have positive effects, such as increasing productivity and efficiency among some of its suppliers, its incredible power has also broken several companies, driving them to bankruptcy and outsourcing. At the same time, I can't rightly concede that Wal-Mart has the best business model of all: when comparing their wholesale division, Sam's Club, with union-friendly competitor Costco, the result is surprising - with 212 fewer stores than Sam's Club, they've had sales of $14 billion dollars more, and made a profit of over $1 billion in the past year. With figures like that, can we trust that Wal-Mart is the best of all possible worlds for consumers, companies, and employees? And worse yet, isn't Wal-Mart's singular control over so many industries a perversion of what the free market was made to do?
9.22.2006
Stay Classy, Maryland
Short post:
Has anybody been following the Maryland Senate campaign? Just today, there's been revelations of some comically ridiculous campaign moves on the part of Republican Michael Steele. Steele happens to be black, and his Democratic opponent is white. If you have followed the campaign for more than 30 seconds, you already know this. However, two things:
1.Steele Democrat signs
If anybody out there is still saying Republicans are proud to be Republicans this year, this image pretty much disproves it. It's not so much the "Democrats for Steele" banner that's ridiculous as the yard signs that on the top line say "Steele", with the word "Democrat" below it. The lesson that people who have seen political yard signs before would take from this is that Michael Steele is the Democratic candidate, of course, but those people are misled. "Steele Democrat" is an appellation for the residents of these houses, "Democrats" who support "Steele." I don't, however, see how anybody could see these signs as anything but misleading, and I would bet that most of the people with these signs in their lawns aren't exactly Democrats.
2."Hey Black People! What's wrong with you?"
I'm sorry, I really was looking for a site with this clip on it that wasn't Wonkette. This ad is really noteworthy for just how ridiculous its claims are. It's true that the Democratic party was responsible for these racist acts - the most recent of which occurred 40 years ago. However, I recognize this blog may have readers who would like to argue which party operates off of racism, and since I don't want to get into a debate over the Southern Strategy, I'll focus on what is stupid enough that I can't believe it made it past focus groups.
"Democrats have bamboozled blacks," says one of the ladies in the ad to the other. The implication from the choice of the word "bamboozled" is that black people are gullible and easily fooled. What other demographic group, in any election, is called "bamboozled", or for that matter, even "fooled" in radio/TV ads? If anybody has any other examples with regard to other demographics from either the left or the right, please let me know. The real kicker, though, is when one of the black ladies in the ad says to the other "we need to think and vote on our own values" before expressing support for Steele - because, of course, they're not going to think on their own, right? (shudder) There's also the part where one of the characters implies that all black people are poor. Stay classy, Maryland!
(How can you lay claim to being the big tent party when you make an ad this condescending?)
Has anybody been following the Maryland Senate campaign? Just today, there's been revelations of some comically ridiculous campaign moves on the part of Republican Michael Steele. Steele happens to be black, and his Democratic opponent is white. If you have followed the campaign for more than 30 seconds, you already know this. However, two things:
1.Steele Democrat signs
If anybody out there is still saying Republicans are proud to be Republicans this year, this image pretty much disproves it. It's not so much the "Democrats for Steele" banner that's ridiculous as the yard signs that on the top line say "Steele", with the word "Democrat" below it. The lesson that people who have seen political yard signs before would take from this is that Michael Steele is the Democratic candidate, of course, but those people are misled. "Steele Democrat" is an appellation for the residents of these houses, "Democrats" who support "Steele." I don't, however, see how anybody could see these signs as anything but misleading, and I would bet that most of the people with these signs in their lawns aren't exactly Democrats.
2."Hey Black People! What's wrong with you?"
I'm sorry, I really was looking for a site with this clip on it that wasn't Wonkette. This ad is really noteworthy for just how ridiculous its claims are. It's true that the Democratic party was responsible for these racist acts - the most recent of which occurred 40 years ago. However, I recognize this blog may have readers who would like to argue which party operates off of racism, and since I don't want to get into a debate over the Southern Strategy, I'll focus on what is stupid enough that I can't believe it made it past focus groups.
"Democrats have bamboozled blacks," says one of the ladies in the ad to the other. The implication from the choice of the word "bamboozled" is that black people are gullible and easily fooled. What other demographic group, in any election, is called "bamboozled", or for that matter, even "fooled" in radio/TV ads? If anybody has any other examples with regard to other demographics from either the left or the right, please let me know. The real kicker, though, is when one of the black ladies in the ad says to the other "we need to think and vote on our own values" before expressing support for Steele - because, of course, they're not going to think on their own, right? (shudder) There's also the part where one of the characters implies that all black people are poor. Stay classy, Maryland!
(How can you lay claim to being the big tent party when you make an ad this condescending?)
9.13.2006
Hate Crimes
Here we have a story of a murder which happened about 20 minutes away from my hometown. I had eaten at the restaurant the victim owned. That's all kind of incidental to what I'm about to start talking about, but just for some background as to why I care about this story - Aladdin Pita made a delicious Adana kebab.
In any case, I've tended agnostic on hate crime legislation. I've always been reasonably affected by the argument that no two identical crimes should be prosecuted differently based on differences in the victims. I've also been open to arguments that we ought not legislate against thought. However, something struck me in this article - children were kept at home out of fear of other attacks. If one entire subgroup of society can be terrorized by an attack, does not that crime cause more harm than another similar crime? At that, I feel it should be prosecuted more harshly. Please, let me know what you think.
In any case, I've tended agnostic on hate crime legislation. I've always been reasonably affected by the argument that no two identical crimes should be prosecuted differently based on differences in the victims. I've also been open to arguments that we ought not legislate against thought. However, something struck me in this article - children were kept at home out of fear of other attacks. If one entire subgroup of society can be terrorized by an attack, does not that crime cause more harm than another similar crime? At that, I feel it should be prosecuted more harshly. Please, let me know what you think.
9.08.2006
Some Things
-So, I've finally learned how to change the sidebar. To your right, you will now find a list of who I surmise to be the best of the local blogs, as well as the ones I tend to follow. Other news sites and such will appear later, to no fanfare.
-Congratulations to Katherine Harris, winner of the Florida Senate Republican Primary. Your exceptional work in the field of insanity has not gone without notice. I would like to apologize, though, for the race in Connecticut - otherwise, you would be the clear favorite for receptor of cathartic liberal wrath this November.
-Pretty much every DI editorial I've read for the past week or two mentions that we have a syphillis epidemic in this county. I can't help but find this funny - mostly because I'm in a nice, committed relationship. I know, I know, it's no laughing matter. But honestly - syphillis. [Insert gratuitous cheap shot at Kam's/Greek system/other place with BJs for sale.]
-Congratulations to Katherine Harris, winner of the Florida Senate Republican Primary. Your exceptional work in the field of insanity has not gone without notice. I would like to apologize, though, for the race in Connecticut - otherwise, you would be the clear favorite for receptor of cathartic liberal wrath this November.
-Pretty much every DI editorial I've read for the past week or two mentions that we have a syphillis epidemic in this county. I can't help but find this funny - mostly because I'm in a nice, committed relationship. I know, I know, it's no laughing matter. But honestly - syphillis. [Insert gratuitous cheap shot at Kam's/Greek system/other place with BJs for sale.]
9.07.2006
ABC Races to the Bottom
So, as you may or may not have heard, ABC plans to run a documentary - er, docudrama about 9/11 entitled The Path to 9/11. Senior consultant on the film and former Republican governor Thomas Kean says:
ABC Entertainment President Steve McPherson concurs:
That's good. It's nice to know that they're going to offer up a complete, accurate account of the failures that led up to 9/11.
But wait!
Apparently, there's a scene wherein the CIA is surrounding bin Laden's house, and along with the Northern Alliance, are about to capture bin Laden. However, they need approval from the Clinton administration to go through with it. Sandy Berger, the representative of said administration, tells them they won't go through with it - because they don't want to run the risk of failure. Then, Sandy Berger hangs up on the CIA agents.
I'm all for movies and media that are unafraid to show bipartisan failure. Unfortunately, Richard Clarke (terrorism czar under Bush, Clinton, and W. Bush) has unequivocally stated thatno part of the above scene actually happened. If you have to fabricate a scene in order to incriminate somebody, there's no way you can lay claim to being even-handed.
On the topic of balance, it's worth noting that ABC has presented advance screenings to Hugh Hewitt, Human Events Online, Rush Limbaugh, Patterico, and other right-wing alt-media sources. On the other hand, nobody from the left has been allowed an advance screening - and in that statement, I include several of the miniseries' stars. Bill Clinton, Sandy Berger, and Madeleine Albright have all been turned down from viewing advance copies of the series to check for accuracy.
In what sense does this movie currently seem even remotely objective? The fact that the makers would need to fabricate entire scenes and hide the movie from the people it's about imply that there isn't much in the way of accuracy here.
More people will see this film than probably anything else on the subject. Telling the whole story of 9/11 will help people better understand the issues involved and what we need to do nationally and locally to prevent another tragedy.
ABC Entertainment President Steve McPherson concurs:
When you take on the responsibility of telling the story behind such an important event, it is absolutely critical that you get it right.
That's good. It's nice to know that they're going to offer up a complete, accurate account of the failures that led up to 9/11.
But wait!
Apparently, there's a scene wherein the CIA is surrounding bin Laden's house, and along with the Northern Alliance, are about to capture bin Laden. However, they need approval from the Clinton administration to go through with it. Sandy Berger, the representative of said administration, tells them they won't go through with it - because they don't want to run the risk of failure. Then, Sandy Berger hangs up on the CIA agents.
I'm all for movies and media that are unafraid to show bipartisan failure. Unfortunately, Richard Clarke (terrorism czar under Bush, Clinton, and W. Bush) has unequivocally stated thatno part of the above scene actually happened. If you have to fabricate a scene in order to incriminate somebody, there's no way you can lay claim to being even-handed.
On the topic of balance, it's worth noting that ABC has presented advance screenings to Hugh Hewitt, Human Events Online, Rush Limbaugh, Patterico, and other right-wing alt-media sources. On the other hand, nobody from the left has been allowed an advance screening - and in that statement, I include several of the miniseries' stars. Bill Clinton, Sandy Berger, and Madeleine Albright have all been turned down from viewing advance copies of the series to check for accuracy.
In what sense does this movie currently seem even remotely objective? The fact that the makers would need to fabricate entire scenes and hide the movie from the people it's about imply that there isn't much in the way of accuracy here.
8.30.2006
The Respect Rankings
Hey, Internet. This is a meme I stole from Urbanagora, home of two good Chambanian bloggers.
The Respect Rankings: Who's Got Character?
It took some time to think these rankings over. As a guy with an ideological dog in the fight, of course I tend to view those on my side as generally being better simply by virtue of their voting records. I'm trying to avoid having too much of a partisan slant here, but of course my judgments of these politicians will be based on what I already know, and I tend to remember unflattering things about Republican pols (and vice versa). Anyways, enough self-conscious bloviating. On with the rankings!
Tie. 1. Tom Coburn - Senate (R-OK)
It's probably surprising to see a conservative at the top of my list. Coburn, however, isn't just any conservative. He is The Conservative. When conservatism is dead and we all travel in socialist rocket cars (ETA: never), children will see Tom Coburn's picture in the Wikipedia entry for "conservatism." The guy is basically the main Republican in the Senate trying to curb pork and earmarks, going so far as to co-sponsor a bill (with Obama!) to make all earmarks and pork legislation available to public scrutiny online. This strong small-government stance has left him with few friends in his own party. At the same time, he appears to be the farthest right Senate member on social issues - during the 2004 campaign season, he railed against rampant lesbianism in high school bathrooms. I wish I were kidding. Oklahoma schools, of course, actually responded to his accusation. I despise Tom Coburn, and I also fear Tom Coburn. But I respect Tom Coburn.
Tie. 1. Russ Feingold - Senate (D-WI)
Brian said it best. I will, however, reiterate - he voted against the PATRIOT Act after 9/11. Also, don't forget his censure resolution. There are people out there who feel about Feingold how I feel about Coburn. The two actually have quite a bit in common by fighting deleterious methods of re-election, and consequently running afoul of their own parties.
3.John Murtha - House (D-PA)
John Murtha made it okay to be anti-war in Washington. John Murtha doesn't care if you try to sue him. John Murtha doesn't care if Jean Schmidt calls him a coward. When the boogeyman goes to sleep every night, he checks his closet for John Murtha.
Others:
Jesse Jackson Jr. (D-IL) - Thankfully, not your father's Jesse Jackson.
Bernie Sanders (I-VT) - Actually claims to be a socialist - stands to win Senate race this fall.
Eliot Spitzer(D-NY) - Pretty much the next big thing.
Barack Obama(D-IL) - Actually deserves to be in the Top 3, but I forgot to put him there.
Arlen Specter(R-PA) - I respect him for his maverick stances. Speaking of mavericks...
Chuck Hagel(R-NE) - What? Who did you expect?
Man, I'm out of practice blogging. Hopefully I'll get back into it.
The Respect Rankings: Who's Got Character?
It took some time to think these rankings over. As a guy with an ideological dog in the fight, of course I tend to view those on my side as generally being better simply by virtue of their voting records. I'm trying to avoid having too much of a partisan slant here, but of course my judgments of these politicians will be based on what I already know, and I tend to remember unflattering things about Republican pols (and vice versa). Anyways, enough self-conscious bloviating. On with the rankings!
Tie. 1. Tom Coburn - Senate (R-OK)
It's probably surprising to see a conservative at the top of my list. Coburn, however, isn't just any conservative. He is The Conservative. When conservatism is dead and we all travel in socialist rocket cars (ETA: never), children will see Tom Coburn's picture in the Wikipedia entry for "conservatism." The guy is basically the main Republican in the Senate trying to curb pork and earmarks, going so far as to co-sponsor a bill (with Obama!) to make all earmarks and pork legislation available to public scrutiny online. This strong small-government stance has left him with few friends in his own party. At the same time, he appears to be the farthest right Senate member on social issues - during the 2004 campaign season, he railed against rampant lesbianism in high school bathrooms. I wish I were kidding. Oklahoma schools, of course, actually responded to his accusation. I despise Tom Coburn, and I also fear Tom Coburn. But I respect Tom Coburn.
Tie. 1. Russ Feingold - Senate (D-WI)
Brian said it best. I will, however, reiterate - he voted against the PATRIOT Act after 9/11. Also, don't forget his censure resolution. There are people out there who feel about Feingold how I feel about Coburn. The two actually have quite a bit in common by fighting deleterious methods of re-election, and consequently running afoul of their own parties.
3.John Murtha - House (D-PA)
John Murtha made it okay to be anti-war in Washington. John Murtha doesn't care if you try to sue him. John Murtha doesn't care if Jean Schmidt calls him a coward. When the boogeyman goes to sleep every night, he checks his closet for John Murtha.
Others:
Jesse Jackson Jr. (D-IL) - Thankfully, not your father's Jesse Jackson.
Bernie Sanders (I-VT) - Actually claims to be a socialist - stands to win Senate race this fall.
Eliot Spitzer(D-NY) - Pretty much the next big thing.
Barack Obama(D-IL) - Actually deserves to be in the Top 3, but I forgot to put him there.
Arlen Specter(R-PA) - I respect him for his maverick stances. Speaking of mavericks...
Chuck Hagel(R-NE) - What? Who did you expect?
Man, I'm out of practice blogging. Hopefully I'll get back into it.
5.18.2006
Introduction/Disclaimer
Welcome to my first explicitly political blog. The purpose of this site is just to give me a place to talk about current politics as well as to explain my personal political beliefs. A fair warning: my writing has a tendency to swing between lofty self-importance and apologetic self-consciousness.
I can't believe I just wrote that.
In any case, I don't expect to get a significant audience for this blog, but that's alright. It's more for me than it is for others. So, without further ado, a couple questions.
What are your politics? I would describe myself as Ezra Klein would - liberal heart, moderate personality. The driving force behind much of my political beliefs is the vitality of class mobility to continued successful capitalism. For this reason, I'm for things like universal health care, funding of schools by statewide taxes, and a highly progressive tax structure, for a couple examples of things which tend to make the poor poorer. I feel very strongly about progressive politics, and though I suppose I've always thought of myself as an indepedent, I'm in practice pretty committed to the Democratic party. I believe it'll be a fair while until I see the Republican party as trustworthy, and I have a host of reasons for not voting third party which I may get into at some point.
At the same time, I'm very open to conflicting points of view, and am willing to debate with those who are civil and honest in their evidence. This is, of course, a difficult thing to find on either side of the blogosphere from time to time, and attempts at constant debate, I worry, would end up looking like Swords Crossed - a good urine-based name, but not nearly as accurate as, say, "Pissing Contest"*. Also, I ask that anybody reading this not engage in conversation with trolls - you're only going to encourage them.
Why the name? One of the most important distinctions to understand is the difference (and similarity) between campaigning and governing. The two are, of course, not mutually exclusive, but the relation between them is not as simple as many tend to think. I'm pretty dedicated to politics myself (and honestly, it's a shame I'm not more policy-knowledgeable), so I'll be focusing more on that within the blog. The whole "user's guide" thing is simply to imply that, as citizens, our participation in the American political system is more effective the more active it is.
Man, I'm really feeling pretentious while writing this. I promise, my writing will probably contain less rumination and more dick jokes than this intro.
So who are you? What do you do? I'm a recent graduate of University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. I was a psychology major, but intend to work in politics. As for what I do for a living, let's just say that's something I'm not talking about, because my "company" has a strict rule about politicizing our jobs. So I ask you, make no assumptions about The Company I keep based on the things I say, and vice versa.
That being said, it's nice to meet you.
-Jon
*And within my very first post, I join the pantheon of blogs that have made fun of the name "Swords Crossed." I've come a long way, baby!
I can't believe I just wrote that.
In any case, I don't expect to get a significant audience for this blog, but that's alright. It's more for me than it is for others. So, without further ado, a couple questions.
What are your politics? I would describe myself as Ezra Klein would - liberal heart, moderate personality. The driving force behind much of my political beliefs is the vitality of class mobility to continued successful capitalism. For this reason, I'm for things like universal health care, funding of schools by statewide taxes, and a highly progressive tax structure, for a couple examples of things which tend to make the poor poorer. I feel very strongly about progressive politics, and though I suppose I've always thought of myself as an indepedent, I'm in practice pretty committed to the Democratic party. I believe it'll be a fair while until I see the Republican party as trustworthy, and I have a host of reasons for not voting third party which I may get into at some point.
At the same time, I'm very open to conflicting points of view, and am willing to debate with those who are civil and honest in their evidence. This is, of course, a difficult thing to find on either side of the blogosphere from time to time, and attempts at constant debate, I worry, would end up looking like Swords Crossed - a good urine-based name, but not nearly as accurate as, say, "Pissing Contest"*. Also, I ask that anybody reading this not engage in conversation with trolls - you're only going to encourage them.
Why the name? One of the most important distinctions to understand is the difference (and similarity) between campaigning and governing. The two are, of course, not mutually exclusive, but the relation between them is not as simple as many tend to think. I'm pretty dedicated to politics myself (and honestly, it's a shame I'm not more policy-knowledgeable), so I'll be focusing more on that within the blog. The whole "user's guide" thing is simply to imply that, as citizens, our participation in the American political system is more effective the more active it is.
Man, I'm really feeling pretentious while writing this. I promise, my writing will probably contain less rumination and more dick jokes than this intro.
So who are you? What do you do? I'm a recent graduate of University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. I was a psychology major, but intend to work in politics. As for what I do for a living, let's just say that's something I'm not talking about, because my "company" has a strict rule about politicizing our jobs. So I ask you, make no assumptions about The Company I keep based on the things I say, and vice versa.
That being said, it's nice to meet you.
-Jon
*And within my very first post, I join the pantheon of blogs that have made fun of the name "Swords Crossed." I've come a long way, baby!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)