Kevin Drum, writer at the Washington Monthly, has stated that three things keep Wal-Mart's prices so low (and thus, make Wal-Mart successful):
1.A spectacularly efficient supply chain and logistics system that's the envy of the industry.
2.A willingness - in fact, an almost palpable enthusiasm - for using their enormous size to beat the lowest possible prices out of their suppliers.
3.A scorched-earth campaign to prevent unions from organizing at Wal-Mart sites, thus keeping wages and benefits as low as possible.
Now, we can all get on board with #1 - productivity is pretty much always a good thing. #3, as you'd imagine, is a real sticking point for many liberals, this one included. I understand some may have a general dislike for unions, but the extent to which Wal-Mart acts to prevent any organized push for higher pay or benefits is ridiculous - the turnover at some of their stores is absurd. #2, though, is what I think is the biggest problem with Wal-Mart, and I would imagine "free-market" conservatives would agree.
Wal-Mart, as it is now, acts as a monopsony - a retailer who actually controls the price at which it purchases from its suppliers. As Ezra notes in the above link, "[t]hey've forced Coke to change their secret recipe, Kraft to lay off thousands of employees, and Vlasic to declare bankruptcy." This is in itself a powerfully deleterious effect independent of wages, and not the only examples of it - since starting to sell their Signature brand at Wal-Mart, Levi's has since closed the last of their U.S. factories. These things, of course, are bad for the companies involved. If you wanted, you could argue that the lost jobs and ruined companies are a small price to pay for more effective consumer prices. However, the street goes both ways. Recently, Wal-Mart has forced major movie studios not to give a better deal to Apple for digital sales than Wal-Mart gets for physical copies. Now, knowing the paltry cost of creating a digital copy compared to an actual DVD, if we're talking efficiency, this is the height of lunacy. However, the studios have no alternative but to comply - Wal-Mart, after all, is responsible for 1/3 of all DVD sales in the US.
The amount of influence Wal-Mart has over so many sectors of the economy is incredible - and though this influence does have positive effects, such as increasing productivity and efficiency among some of its suppliers, its incredible power has also broken several companies, driving them to bankruptcy and outsourcing. At the same time, I can't rightly concede that Wal-Mart has the best business model of all: when comparing their wholesale division, Sam's Club, with union-friendly competitor Costco, the result is surprising - with 212 fewer stores than Sam's Club, they've had sales of $14 billion dollars more, and made a profit of over $1 billion in the past year. With figures like that, can we trust that Wal-Mart is the best of all possible worlds for consumers, companies, and employees? And worse yet, isn't Wal-Mart's singular control over so many industries a perversion of what the free market was made to do?
3 comments:
Jon,
As always, you have made a sharp, cogent response. I hope to have time to investigate your claims, but for the moment I just have an initial reaction-type question.
Assuming Wal-Mart, just as any rational actor, wants the best for itself, why would it employ practices that force their suppliers into "bankruptcy." They need their supplies just as bad the supplier needs them. It would seem to me silly for Wal-Mart to kill off all suppliers, except for maybe one, since then that one remaining supplier isn't competing against any others and their prices will be higher when supplying to Wal-Mart.
It's possible that profits will be transferred from suppliers to Wal-Mart, but those profits will simultaneously be transferred to consumers.
Also, I have no problems with outsourcing. Check out my article that is linked from my Wal-Mart post. I believe that we insource more jobs than we outsource. Also, outsourced jobs still account for a small fraction of the total jobs in America. Every decade millions of jobs are created and destroyed, but it has almost always been the case, in America at least, that more have been created.
Jon, your argument that Wal-Mart is bad for many suppliers does not prove that that is bad for the country. Your essential conclusions are that inefficient businesses go bakrupt, or outsourcing becomes more common. Well, as Billy pointed out, the latter is a phenomenon that provides a net boon to society (even while carrying marginal costs - but then again, what economic action DOESN'T carry marginal costs?). Secondly, the former doesn't make any sense in the context of national well-being because there's no valid reason why inefficient businesses should survive. The entire point of free market competition is to eliminate those who can't compete.
Billy and Josh,
Thanks for commenting.
In response, I guess I can say it wasn't the best idea to bring up outsourcing as an issue - people are pretty strongly split over whether or not that's a good thing. However, Wal-Mart pricing its suppliers out of business is a real problem - Vlasic pickles in particular are perhaps the best known example, and their situation is better explained in the link above about Levi's. In short, Wal-Mart has a policy of dictating a price to its suppliers - uniformly lower than that supplier sells to any other retailer, and a significantly lower profit margin - and Wal-Mart will lower that price on a seasonal basis. In Vlasic's case, this pattern actually brought their profit margin to zero - and then below zero. Vlasic (like most retailers) holds almost no cards in a situation like this - Wal-mart is larger than its five largest competitors combined, and the company is responible for 20% of all retail sales in the country. Now, seeing as these sales used to come from somewhere else, opting not to sell at Wal-Mart is not an option most suppliers have. At the same time, this isn't nearly as large a problem for Wal-Mart - though it's nice for them to be able to sell Vlasic pickles, for instance, it doesn't help them by making them much money at all. Items such as the pickles are loss leaders - items with low profit margin designed to bring people into the store so they can spend more on items with higher profit margins. Wal-Mart doesn't particularly suffer by not being able sell Vlasic - they can get away with simply selling their house brand, and looking to other products to serve as loss leaders. This strategy is in place, and it does damage (and occasionally ruin) suppliers, but the function those products serve at Wal-Mart stores makes the strategy a net gain for the retailer.
And more to the point regarding Josh's comment - this strategy is an example of a market that isn't actually free. A single corporation here is capable of dictating prices to companies in numerous industries, and not necessarily to the long-term benefit of those companies. If Wal-Mart didn't have this extreme amoutn of influence, this argument would be moot - unfortunately, that's not the case. And Wal-Mart's bargaining doesn't necessarily pass savings along to us - videos for sale in the iTunes music store will be more expensive because of Wal-Mart's insistence.
Were the government controlling prices for goods in the way this single corporation does, we would rightly refer to it as communism. The fact that they have a board of directors isn't making me trust them any more than I would trust such a government.
Post a Comment