Here we have a story of a murder which happened about 20 minutes away from my hometown. I had eaten at the restaurant the victim owned. That's all kind of incidental to what I'm about to start talking about, but just for some background as to why I care about this story - Aladdin Pita made a delicious Adana kebab.
In any case, I've tended agnostic on hate crime legislation. I've always been reasonably affected by the argument that no two identical crimes should be prosecuted differently based on differences in the victims. I've also been open to arguments that we ought not legislate against thought. However, something struck me in this article - children were kept at home out of fear of other attacks. If one entire subgroup of society can be terrorized by an attack, does not that crime cause more harm than another similar crime? At that, I feel it should be prosecuted more harshly. Please, let me know what you think.
1 comment:
I read this post a few days ago, and am just now getting the chance to post my thoughts on this. I hadn't thought about the issue in quite some time, so thanks for bringing it up. The story you link to is awful.
My first thoughts on hate crime legislation center on the belief that the argument in favor of it should not follow the "hate crimes are more heinous than other crimes" line. Judging which of two murders is more heinous is a wholly subjective practice. Personally, I'd argue that crimes against children are more heinous than hate crimes. I find it difficult to imagine arguing to the father of a murdered daughter that the deterrent effects of a stronger sentence for murdering me because I'm gay should not have equally applied to his daughter merely because murdering me for being gay is "more heinous."
So I would agree that no two identical crimes should be prosecuted differently based on differences in the victims. But I would argue that two identical crimes shoudl be prosecuted differently based on differences in the perpetrators. We in fact do this all the time in the criminal justice system when a judge or jury takes into effect aggravating and mitigating circumstances surrounding a given crime: a cold-blooded serial killer murdering without remorse gets a harsher sentence than a psychologically abused wife who murders her husband gets a harsher sentence than a man who kills because he is legally insane.
Hate crime legislation merely takes the extra step of institutionalizing the motive of hate as an aggravating circumstance worthy of a stricter sentence.
I think this is a reasonable step for a couple reasons. First, there are sadly communities in this country in which a jury might consider the motive of hate a mitigating rather than an aggravating circumstance (as demonstrated by the occasionally attempted "gay panic" defense). Hate crime legislation ensures fair sentencing in these communities.
Second, hate crime legislation serves a statement against the broader pathology of racism, sexism, homophobia, etc. in this country. One can argue that this is "legislating thought," but there is no threat here to free expression. Again, it is merely a determination that the hatred present in the perpetrator of a hate crime is a quality that warrants a stronger punishment for that perpetrator. That's not because his crime is more heinous, but because his crime is motivated by a mentality our society wishes to discourage (without censoring). Unlike other murders, these murders represent a deeper problem in our society. That doesn't make them more heinous, but it does make them worthy of a harsher punishment as part of an effort to eliminate that deeper problem.
Post a Comment