10.20.2006

Malignant Comedy

Hey, I return. Sorry, I was busy hanging out with Harvey Danger.

Here's an editorial Jess and I worked on today. With luck, it may appear in the DI... or not, whatever:



The infamous “Tacos and Tequila” party has ignited a great deal of discussion about racial stereotyping on our campus. The party was reprehensible, but symptomatic of a larger problem – the embrace of stereotyping as a response to political correctness (the new Red Menace.) Just a few weeks after this party, comedian Carlos Mencia will visit the U of I Assembly Hall as part of his Punisher tour. By looking at the style and popularity of Mencia, it is not hard to see how college students could possibly think that wearing wife beaters and stuffing one’s shirt to appear pregnant at a Hispanic themed party could be acceptable.

The issue with Carlos Mencia’s comedic stylings is inflamed by his own protestations on the matter. Although his standard defense of his work runs along the lines of “it’s only comedy”, this proclamation, often delivered within one of his standup routines, acknowledges a truth that strengthens the appeal of Richard Pryor, Jeff Foxworthy, and yes, Dave Chappelle – it’s not just comedy, it’s commentary. Mencia’s strident tone and oh-no-he-didn’t “courageousness” serve to portray him as a truthteller – a court jester who says what others are forbidden to say – but it’s a poor fit. His routine – dependent on racial, religious, and sexual divisions for success – is no revelation of outlawed truths, but rather a lazy recitation of stereotypes we’ve all heard before.

The Chappelle comparisons, trumpeted by critics and fans alike, illustrate how far apart the two are. Dave Chappelle, vanished star of his own sketch comedy show, built his career on the absurdity of society’s ethnic divisions. Even sketches he found too controversial (most notably the “race pixie” sketch, in which people of different ethnicities are tormented by the pressure to conform to stereotypes via miniature minstrels and the like) showed human beings at the other end of the joke. Chappelle’s Show was a rare achievement in the way it opened up racial dialogue. Sadly, Chappelle left his show out of concern that his audience might misread the message as an acceptance of stereotyping. This concern was apparently well-founded, as evidenced by Mencia’s popularity and the Tacos and Tequila debacle.

Carlos Mencia makes a point of telling us that as a comedian, he’s only telling jokes. However, comedy is not a benign force, and as a leading comedian, his divisive brand of humor influences acceptable discourse in society at large. It’s unfortunate that he received his platform as a result of the work of Dave Chappelle, a comedian who opened up a critical dialogue on race in a way that only comedy could. Mencia’s work, however, demolishes the progress made by Chappelle’s Show – a sad case of one step forward, two steps back.

No comments: